It is strange to me to think of the divide in our country over the issue of illegal immigration. I don’t understand the dilemma, possibly because I have stopped to think it through, possibly because I simply don’t know enough.
As a Christian, I find the relationship between justice and mercy a compelling argument, though I also understand that for the relationship of mercy and justice to work, the entity granting mercy cannot be the same as the one fulfilling justice, and have both sides satisfied. It just is not possible.
So… now we have a problem, a large problem. The main issues as I see them?
- The base law of the country is being broken
- Porous, insecure border.
- A large group of people, mainly Latino , and mainly from Mexico.
- cheap labor
- no medical insurance
- Local law enforcement problems
- Mixed citizenship families
- Increasingly angry legal citizenry
So… why do we have this problem? It is simple; America is prosperous and peaceful compared to Mexico and many other nations in the world. We became this way because the people of this country knew that fleeing somewhere else was not an option: there was no freedom-loving ‘America’ to border-hop to in the mid 1700’s. In fact, the American founding fathers were fighting against the largest ‘democratic’ nation in the world, England, which did not recognize their ‘rights’. Let me say this in a clear manner, instead saying that the grass is greener on the other side of the fence, and hopping over to the ‘greener’ side, the founders of America made their side greener; they fixed what they had, worked from within, to make a better nation. They threw off what they saw as a corrupted, insecure, oppressive government which did not listen or recognize their ‘human rights’.
While there are other issues stemming from illegal immigration, I find these to be the most problematic. (Others may disagree).
So… let’s look into this problem:
1. Base law of of the country is being broken. How? Illegal immigration is a violation of current U.S immigration law… hence ‘illegal’. That is not the base law of the country… the U.S. Constitution is. The U.S. Constitution requires that the Federal Government protect and secure the borders of the country…which the federal government has refused to do for decades. The security problem is becoming much more apparent with the abductions, murder, and kidnappings happening all across the border. American citizens are under attack, in their own homes and on their own land, along the border. If this was happening to any other major nation in the world, anyone witnessed crossing the border illegally would be shot on sight. But in America, the basic right of calling on the government for security, federal and state, has been ignored and American citizens have been abandoned and ignored by the government charged to protect them, and which they pay for. The insecurity and abandonment of American citizens cannot be ignored and must be fixed immediately. The U.S. Federal government is currently in open violation of the core principle and purpose for its creation, the citizens have just cause to call on the federal government for security and redress. This is a complete violation of the basic rights of the citizens.
2. Porous, insecure border. What does this mean? It is not just the citizens on the border who are compromised because of the inaction of the government. Mexico is also compromised, as is the middle mainland and political process of the U.S. Securing the border is the first step in protecting the citizens, and must be done in conjunction with security for the citizens all across the U.S. Deported criminals, (Anyone deported is technically a ‘criminal’ because they broke the law and warranted deportation), simply return across the unmonitored border, to return to their illegal activity.
3. A large, mainly Latino, Mexican illegal population. This is a problem only insofar as the implementation of ANY effective law or action used to remedy the situation. No matter what action is passed, it will be viewed as ‘racist’, regardless of actual existence of any bias, because, it will be predominantly targeting a single racial and national group: Latino Mexican immigrants. A law may not target or affect any one group, other than immigration status, but if effective when enforced, the law will effect the one main group. This also is a major problem when it comes to language and cultural issues. Most of the United states now is required to print all documents in two languages. This inflates the price of government, and fosters continued seclusion on the illegal population.
4. Cheap labor. Cheap labor is an interesting problem as it not only depresses the cost of labor in the United States, damaging the labor market for legal citizens, but it depresses production costs and production quality. Cheap labor usually means uneducated and unskilled labor, (usually but not always, I have found some amazing quality from immigrant workers). The United States has not yet felt the impact of raising the minimum wage, of actual policy, because the labor industry has used illegal immigrants as a stop-gap for cost/revenue balancing, creating a labor-bubble in the economy. This problem exists on both sides of the ‘immigration reform’ issue. If made citizens, the cheap labor will dry-up due to minimum wage. Cheap labor will also disappear if current immigration laws are enforced. The only way the market will not be required to adjust is if illegal immigration is NEVER addressed or fixed, in which case all the other problems simply increase.
5. No Medical Insurance. The Lack of Medical insurance is a well-known sticking point against illegal immigration. According to U.S. law, hospitals cannot turn away patients from emergency room care. Consequently, hospitals eat the cost of any non-paying emergency care, and illegal immigrants flock to the emergency room for care… basic… median, and emergency care. This causes a backlog of patients and increases waiting times and access to emergency care in emergency rooms across the country.
6. Local Law Enforcement Problems. The local law enforcement already has issues with solving crimes, and violent crimes, among the illegal populations, as the illegal immigrants are much less likely to report crime, or witness to officers about crime. Consequently, local law enforcement is compromised whenever they deal with crimes that impact or cross the illegal immigrant population, regardless of whether the illegal immigrants have been party to the crime in question.
7. Mixed Citizenship Families. This becomes a very sticky situation in regards to deportation, the required legal punishment due to illegal immigrants… yet many illegal immigrants have legal citizen children. What to do to the families, the legal citizens?
8. Increasingly angry legal citizenry. By tacitly or openly supporting illegal immigration the Federal Government is inciting and fomenting revolt of the legal populace and, in this case, fostering and sowing the seeds of racism due to the majority of the illegal immigration consists of one race and nationality, and their status as illegal immigrants limits their social and economic potential.
What do do about this? How do we fix it? Well, the solution is simple, but difficult. Secure the border then enforce current law. If immigration reform is found to be required, (I believe it is), it can be dealt with after the holes in the border have been dealt with. The argument that current illegal aliens have a say in the stake of the nation because they have worked and invested in this country for so long, is completely irresponsible as any extension of U.S. constitutional law to those not covered under the constitution, (non citizens), is an empirical act and denies the sovereignty of their host nation and the individual. Simply put, legally, extending the constitution to cover citizens of any other nation, regardless of whether they are in this country or not, imposes the U.S. legal system on the world, as a world government system. While you could argue that it has already been done, it would be illegal under the constitution itself, as due representation and self-determination has not be provided. if it has been done, it must stop. If it is going to be stopped, it MUST stop here, in the U.S., where the constitution actually has an effect.
The call for mercy in government action by the United States is an appealing, yet impossible to satisfy call, especially when it comes from other nations which themselves do not offer such ‘mercy’ to illegal immigration in their own borders, (like Mexico). If the United States grants any amount of ‘mercy’ to the illegal immigrants currently in the country, they will be, once again, offering incentive to break the law. If the United States is to be a law-abiding nation, if the rule of law is to be preserved, the human rights we hold dear - by law, then the full extent of the law must be enforced.
The main problems facing enforcement are, the border which must be secured first, and what to do with split citizenship families. The only rational option that can be offered, is to allow the families themselves to choose. If the minor children, who are citizens, wish to stay, then they should be allowed to. There is no other option under current law, which is the only way they can be tried. You cannot remove their citizenship once they have it simply due to parentage. (Though laws may be crafted to deny citizenship to further children born to illegal immigrants, this is not currently the case.) While it is not possible to deport American citizens because their parents are being deported, it is also against U.S. law to keep the citizens from leaving. If they wish to stay with their parents, they may. But the choice should be theirs.
Hopefully, the large mass of immigrants deported from the U.S. will press for political change in their own country, like the founders of America did in this country, instead of hopping to the ‘greener’ side of the fence… and illegal immigration would no longer be a problem.
America has done Mexico a disfavor by taking the enterprising population away. If a call to mercy is to be heeded by the U.S. government, it would be to show mercy to our own citizens by enforcing our laws and to return, or encourage the return of, the enterprising Mexican citizens to their native lands where they may affect positive change of their own. (A minimum of 15 million people will have an affect.) Currently, illegal immigrants are a pseudo-slave, “untouchable”, group in a pseudo caste system which the businesses and now political figures rely and stand on. They deserve so much better, but the collective illegal immigrant situation cannot be elevated by figures from the outside; it must be done from within. The laws must be upheld. If it is not, it is impossible to raise those in social shadows, those who exist outside the light of the rule of law, by turning that light off for the rest of the country. The illegal immigrants MUST come out of the shadows and accept the rule of law if they are to be protected by it. The greatest mercy that could be offered them is that of honesty and honor. Accept the rule of law, and then, if Mexico is not changed politically, improved, by the influx of these her people, then they would be free to apply for legal immigration status after reform has been completed. I have no problem with that, in fact, I would encourage it.
If you wish monetary ‘mercy’… the U.S. people are the most generous people in the world. The government donates more in international aid than most countries’ GDP. The private charities of the U.S. give out hundreds of billions of dollars per year. If the general public finds a cause worth while, they will give, and give generously.
…I don’t know if I have left much out. This is a huge rambling rant. Please share your thoughts.
Brice Bitter